xtue3e4吧 关注:70贴子:1,079

【Peer Review】话题五

只看楼主收藏回复

what are the problem of peer review in our class? and what's your advice to make it more efficient?


IP属地:湖南来自iPhone客户端1楼2016-03-31 19:32回复
    (519) Since peer review is to help us edit and revise our witten texts, then we should have clear guidelines and serious attitude. But we don't have fixed number group. So when it came to peer review, many of our classmates did the job with very casual attitude. And on the other hand, it is exactly that we still do not have such good grammar basis to find out problems. So in my personal view, before we edit the papers, we should read more model essays written by our peers and learn more typical and native English expressions. Then we also need some fixed groups. After editting other members' papers, everyone except writer can give a score. Then choosing the best one as the group represent to be read in class. At last, having compared with other groups' papers, the excellent one(or two) can be chosen by teacher as the model essay for the next time.


    IP属地:湖北来自Android客户端4楼2016-04-01 14:05
    回复
      (511) I think that the problem in our class is we students do not pay much attention to it.We don't take it as a serious thing. And my advice is that each time we ask one student to be reponsible to a group(not so much people,3 or 4is ok),and the next time wo change to another student to be responsible.In this way,students would be serious at least for one time,because it is his or her duty.(But by the way, I don't think this is a solution that can solve the fundemental problem.)


      5楼2016-04-01 14:57
      回复
        (505)There also exist some problems to be solved in the process of peer review,and the solution is given to readers in the article,teachers and students should do some efforts together.


        来自iPhone客户端8楼2016-04-01 23:07
        回复
          (525)In class, we will regard it as a task, and don't value it. It's just killing time for someone. I think, we should set up study groups, and do it consciously in spare time.


          来自Android客户端9楼2016-04-01 23:22
          回复
            (632)Taking it as a task is the main problem and less communication about texts on revision. Setting up many groups and choose an excellent may be the effective ways.


            来自iPhone客户端10楼2016-04-01 23:49
            回复
              522
              well, when the teacher asks us to begin the peer revision, it seems that many people don't feel like communicating with each other, in addition, some students are not good at grammar therefore they helps little in peer revision. As a result,they loses interest in peer revision.
              Sorry, i can't think of any efficient ways to promote it at present.


              12楼2016-04-03 09:40
              回复
                (533)In my opinion,the problem of peer review in our class is that we just regard it as a task.so when we finished it we usually put it on the other place and not treat it with a serious attitude.so i hope we can draw a lot attention on it or have some reward and punishment system on it.Well,that's just my thoughts.


                来自手机贴吧13楼2016-04-03 09:56
                回复
                  (515) In our class, I think our class always try to let us be more relaxed, but sometimes it is too relaxed to let us pay attention to the importance of it, proper relaxing is comfortable, maybe sometimes the tasks should be serious.


                  15楼2016-04-03 13:40
                  回复
                    (507)As far as I'm concerned,the problem of peer review in our class is whether peer reviewers are given clear guidelines so that students know what to look for and what kinds of feedback will be most helpful.So according to this problem, my advice is to define both of the role of the role of the students and the role of the teacher during the whole process,so that everyone know their work clealy.


                    来自手机贴吧16楼2016-04-03 13:45
                    收起回复
                      (531)All of us focus on grammar and spelling,we seldom realize how others organize,intend to tell us.so if we all know the rules of this game,things will absolutely change.cause we are going to be more legible,collaborative,and positive.


                      17楼2016-04-03 13:53
                      回复
                        (633)in our class,we usually take peer revision into presenter’s task, and some students are not good at grammar,so they can not keep up with and lose interest as time passes.In my opinion,we can do not get too complicated in peer revision.


                        18楼2016-04-03 15:19
                        回复
                          125:I think the most imprtant problem is the intrests of the peer revision.Sometimes, the classmates are not so relucant to do the work. My advice is to improve the intrests of the students. For example, we can change the way to do the peer revision. Try to share your composition with the students who are not familiar with you , the partner doesn't know your name is better.


                          19楼2016-04-03 16:38
                          收起回复
                            (509)As far as I am concerned,the problem of peer revision in our class is that we have little time to do that in class,and after class, we may forget this thing.That is to say,we do not treat it seriously. My advice is to divide students into many groups and choose a leader to be responsible for that.


                            IP属地:湖南来自Android客户端20楼2016-04-03 18:08
                            回复
                              (521)There are several problems in our class. For example, we don't pay much attention to it. second, we do not have much time to do it. Then, when we are doing this, what we concerned are the basic grammatical problems, we seldom pay attentionto the deeper ones.


                              来自Android客户端21楼2016-04-04 10:23
                              回复